A frame-by-frame review of a 5-iron swing from the November 4 session at Mariners Point, measured with the full reference frame (grid, center lines and diagonals), plus the complete range-screen readout. Club identified from the video. Second 5-iron report in the logbook.
Bottom line: a solid 5-iron that found the target. 166 yds total, 156 carry, 106 mph ball speed, finishing 25 ft from the 159-yd flag. It curved 19 ft left and landed at 38°, so it released ~10 yds.
The swing is quick and athletic: ~0.50 s backswing, ~0.32 s downswing, hips that hold their depth, and a held finish. The one pattern from all his irons is strongest here: the head drops about 6 in by the time the lead arm is parallel and ~7 in by impact. With a long iron that costs ball speed and keeps launch high (19° vs 14° LPGA).
25 ft from a 159-yd flag, solid strike, balanced finish held while he watches the ball.
The dip happens in the first 0.2 s. Keep the cap on its line through the takeaway.
Hands ahead at impact: 19° down to ~15° turns height into carry with a long iron.
| Metric | André #2 (Nov 4) | André #1 (Oct 2) | LPGA avg | PGA avg |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ball speed | 106 mph | 108 mph | 112 mph | 132 mph |
| Club speed (est.) | ~76–78 mph | ~77–80 mph | 79 mph | 94 mph |
| Carry | 156 yds | 159 yds | 161 yds | 194 yds |
| Flat carry | 155 yds | 157 yds | — | — |
| Total | 166 yds | 169 yds | — | — |
| Launch angle | 19° | 19° | 14.3° | 12.1° |
| Apex | 70 ft (23 yds) | 72 ft | 25 yds | 31 yds |
| Landing angle | 38° | 40° | 43° | 47° |
| Curve | 19 ft left | 20 ft | — | — |
| Hang time | 5.3 s | 5.4 s | — | — |
| Proximity | 25 ft ★ (159-yd flag) | not shown | — | — |
★ first 5-iron with a proximity reading. Club speed isn't on the screen: at a long-iron smash of ~1.36–1.40, 106 mph means about 76–78 mph. Curve direction read from the brighter arrow (left). LPGA/PGA: classic TrackMan Tour averages (5-iron).
What it means: almost a copy of his October 5-iron (−2 mph, −3 yds), so this is his stable 5-iron: LPGA-level speed, but launched ~5° high and landing ~5° shallow, so it runs. Same speed with ~15° launch should give ~160–162 yds carry and a steeper landing.
30 frames per second, so each time is accurate to about ±0.03 s. Takeaway starts at ~30.95 s, the club reaches the top at ~31.44 s, and impact is at ~31.75 s.
| Group | Backswing | Downswing | Ratio |
|---|---|---|---|
| André (5-iron #2, Nov 4) | ~0.50 s | ~0.32 s | ~1.6:1 |
| André (5-iron #1, Oct 2) | ~0.53 s | ~0.28 s | ~1.9:1 |
| André (8-iron #1, same session) | ~0.50 s | ~0.28 s | ~1.8:1 |
| PGA Tour (Tour Tempo, "24/8") | ~0.80 s | ~0.27 s | 3:1 |
Tour figure: John Novosel, Tour Tempo. Frames: takeaway 74, top 89, impact 98–99.
What it means: his rhythm is consistent across clubs, quick back and quick down. A slightly longer, smoother backswing (~0.6–0.7 s) would bring the ratio toward 2.5:1 and give the body time to rotate without diving toward the ball.
Nine key positions, filmed from behind (down-the-line). The target is into the picture. Times are from takeaway.
Photos are numbered in the order they happen in the swing.
Left: impact close-up (frames 97–100): ball at rest, clubhead at the ball, ball gone. Right: the sole shown to the camera after the swing, a clear "5" with no bar under it (on his clubs only the 6 and 9 have the bar).
Club: 5-Iron, read on the sole in the video. Logged as report #2.
| Measure (vs address) | Lead arm parallel | Top | Impact | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Head, height | ~6 in down | ~3½ in down | ~7 in down | Fix early, fast dip |
| Head, toward ball | ~2½ in | ~4 in | ~1½ in | Watch moves with the dip |
| Hips, depth (toward ball) | ~2 in back | ~2 in back | ≈ 0 in | Good no early extension |
| Hips, height | ≈ same | ~1 in up | ~1 in up | Good stable |
| Hands at impact | — | — | ~2 in fwd · ~1 in down | Watch could lead more |
| Club (Nov 4) | Carry | Total | Ball speed | Launch | Head drop at impact |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5-Iron #2 | 156 yds | 166 yds | 106 mph | 19° | ~7 in |
| 8-Iron #2 | 123 yds | 126 yds | 94.0 mph | 23° | ~4½ in |
| 8-Iron #1 | 122 yds | 125 yds | 93.5 mph | 22° | ~6 in |
The 5-iron flies ~33 yds past the 8-iron, about 11 yds per club, which is healthy long-iron gapping. Across all three swings the head drop is the common thread: every club launches 4–5° above the LPGA window.
First 2 ft of the backswing with the cap still: turn the chest, don't bow toward the ball. 10 slow takeaways, then full swings.
Feel the hands over the lead thigh at impact. Target: 14–16° launch with the same 106 mph.
Keep using a target (159 yds here): proximity is the best scorecard for a 5-iron.
Confidence: high on ball flight, club ID and tempo; moderate on head and hip distances.